Is it not Chance that decides whether the sun shines?

Is it not Chance that decides whether the sun shines?

It is the middle of the morning, soon after the appropriate time for brunch has passed and two men are seated in the visitors’ chairs in an office. They are both in their shirtsleeves wearing equally non-descript office attire. There is an unoccupied desk behind them and an old oil-heater next to the second speaker who is seated next to a wall. It is the office of the first speaker though this he does not realise.  The curtain rises on the two seated and already in conversation, they mime their speaking as the opening music (The song ‘Metal Vacation’ by Ches Smith, a comical but unnerving piece for xylophone) continues to play, loudly enough that even the front-row of the audience would not expect to hear them and when the music ceases abruptly they are already speaking.

Man 1: I have an honours degree in Swedish.

Man 2: You studied Swedish?

Man 1: No I studied mathematics, the degree itself was written in some sort of High German, which I just assumed was Swedish. Can’t understand a word of it, it could be a diploma in obstetrics for all I know.

Man 2: I studied nothing.

Man 1: Interesting, how did you come to that field?

Man 2: With some ease, I left things up to serendipity. Serendipity gave me nothing.

Man 1: Interesting. I’ve never been one to accept serendipity as a predisposition to anything except winning at cards.

Man 2: You should submit yourself to it; it surely beats other methods for deciding.

Man 1: I suppose you’re right, to decide on one course of action or another is to assume one has the gift of perfect foresight and also the ability to execute their decision.

Man 2: True, no decision can be perfectly assessed against its opposite, except in retrospect. And of course, my deciding to leave the room right now is quite aside from my actually leaving the room, especially since you’ve chained me to this oil-heater.

Man 1: I’ve done no such thing.

Man 2: So you haven’t. I suppose I’ll leave the room then.

Man 1: Do stay; it’s so rare I have visitors.

Man 2: Certainly. But only if you explain to me how it is you decided to study mathematics when you had no idea where your greatest aptitude lay.

Man 1: I knew it didn’t not lay in mathematics.

Man 2: Yes, but you didn’t know where it least didn’t lie.

Man 1: Of course you are right, but would you have me try everything?

Man 2: Only if that’s how it happened.

Man 1: But how else does one discover his greatest aptitude?

Man 2: Aptitude is not the point.

Man 1: Listen, I get what you mean. I suppose I only nervously accept serendipity inasmuch as it is something I cannot even pretend to affect. I also don’t accept that serendipity has my interests more in mind than my own mind.

Man 2: Well I should let you know that my use of escitalopram has helped in my endeavours to accept what’s given to me by fate.

Man 1: I don’t believe that Serendipity-Acceptance is a known side effect of escitalopram.

Man 2: Maybe it’s Serendipity-Reliance that it causes.

Man 1: I didn’t see that on the Product-Information pamphlet either.

Man 2: Since when were mathematicians privy to the information included with anti-depressant medications?

Man 1: Touché. Has it at least had the intended effect?

Man 2: What?

Man 1: The escitalopram.

Man 2: Oh no. I’m quite depressed. But not in particular by those things that I have accepted from serendipity…

Man 1: Which are…

Man 2: Namely nothing.

Man 1: By what then, may I ask?

Man 2: The weather mostly.

Man 1: Fortuitous then that today brings us sun.

Man 2: I think sir that you insult Newton by suggesting that fortune has anything to do with the sun. Though of course I have no access to the forces of determination that were long ago set in a motion which today brings us sun.

Man 1: I suppose I should have guessed your affinity for Newton.

Man 2: Yes, but I would never have guessed your haphazard approach to the weather.

About the Author

Samuel L is the naturalest, naturopathic practitioner of natural medicine, working within conventional Western Chi. His expert opinion has been sought in three class-actions regarding the utility of things. He subscribes to a number of eminent publications, in magazine form. His opinions on most topics are held in high regard. You may contact him at work, or just leave a message. He lives in Melbourne, Victoria and likes what you've done with the place.